Tuesday, November 29, 2022

California Laws Generally Apply Only within Borders of State

Since the pandemic, my company has been allowing employees to work from home. Without informing our human resources department, several of these employees have moved to other states. Now that these employees are living in other states, do the California overtime laws apply to these employees?

The short answer is “no.” Generally speaking, the laws of each state apply only within the borders of that state. In “legalese,” there is a presumption against extraterritorial application of the laws of a state.

That means that unless a state specifically states in its laws that it intends to apply those laws across state borders, then the law applies only to individuals within the state.

Court Ruling

This issue was discussed in the California Supreme Court case of Sullivan v. Oracle Corporation ((2011) 51 Cal 4th 1191). In that case, employees who lived outside of California were coming to California several times a year and were working within our state for days or weeks at a time.

These plaintiffs alleged that they were entitled to overtime under California law for the time they were working in California. The court agreed with this assertion and granted them damages.

These same plaintiffs, however, claimed that they were entitled to the protections of California laws while they were in their home states as well.

The court disagreed, citing the presumption against the extension of California law across state borders.

There is no language in the overtime or unfair competition laws regarding the extension of those laws across state lines. Moreover, the vast majority of laws in California do not extend beyond the borders of this state.

Exception

One of the few exceptions is in the area of sexual harassment prevention training. If a company has an employee living in another state who is supervising employees within California, that employee is subject to the harassment prevention training mandate.

If you have employees working in other states, in most circumstances, those employees will be covered by the laws of that other state, and not the laws of California.

We advise our members who have employees working in other states to contact experts in the laws of those states for questions regarding the laws that apply to those employees.


Column based on questions asked by callers on the Labor Law Helpline, a service to California Chamber of Commerce preferred and executive members. For expert explanations of labor laws and Cal/OSHA regulations, not legal counsel for specific situations, call (800) 348-2262 or submit your question at www.hrcalifornia.com.

David Leporiere
David Leporiere
David Leporiere joined the CalChamber in 2014 and currently serves as an HR adviser. Specializing in employment and labor law on behalf of businesses and business owners, he also has provided training for employers on a wide variety of employment-related topics, including discrimination, harassment, wage and hour, and leave laws and regulations. He holds a J.D. from the University of California, Davis.

Related Articles

Cal/OSHA Considers Removing Exclusion Pay Mandate from New COVID Rule

As the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) prepares to vote on the next iteration of California’s COVID-19 emergency regulation, one important change being considered is whether to extend California employers’ obligation...

COVID-19 Regulation: Cal/OSHA Makes Big Changes Ahead of December Vote

California employers may want to get out their measuring tape — because the size (in cubic feet) of a workspace just became an important element of COVID-19 compliance. Last Thursday and Friday (October 13–14), the...

CalChamber Calls for Changes to Nonemergency COVID Draft Rule

The Cal/OSHA Standards Board’s draft proposal to extend the state’s COVID-19 regulation for another two years — with some significant changes from the COVID-19 emergency regulation — still needs adjustments, the California Chamber of...