Saturday, November 26, 2022

CalChamber Opposes Tax on Plastic/Goods Packaging

Supports Taxpayer Protection Ballot Measure

The California Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors last week voted to oppose the California Plastic Waste Reduction Regulations Initiative, which proposes a new tax of up to $0.01 on every piece of single-use plastic packaging and food ware sold in California beginning in 2022.

The CalChamber Board also voted to support the Taxpayer Protection and Government Accountability Act, a proposed initiative that would amend the California Constitution to change procedures for approving state and local tax increases to improve information and accountability to taxpayers and strengthen voter approval procedures.

Tax on Packaging

OPPOSE: The California Plastic Waste Reduction Regulations Initiative

The California Plastic Waste Reduction Regulations Initiative would impose a tax on virtually all consumer goods packaging, including packaging for food products, and a tax on some single-use plastic products. If enacted, this new tax on businesses selling in or into California will also increase for inflation beginning in 2030.

The Legislative Analyst’s Office has estimated the tax would be “several billion dollars” annually, with some industry estimations coming in as high as $8 billion a year.

Of particular concern is that much of the tax revenue from this initiative is diverted to special interest programs to address a variety of environmental concerns, rather than being focused on reinvesting into the recycling and composting systems necessary to ensure a circular economy can be achieved.

Additionally, this initiative creates a new source reduction requirement on businesses to reduce by 25% the total amount of single-use plastic packaging and food ware by both weight and number of items sold by 2030.

Further, the initiative bans food vendors from distributing expanded polystyrene food service containers and establishes other requirements on producers, such as mandatory take-back and deposit programs, recyclable, reusable, refillable and compostable mandates.

This source reduction mandate is infeasible and fails to account for population growth. Moreover, the initiative ignores infrastructure needs to comply with these requirements, such as permitting challenges and technological needs, and it would exacerbate supply chain problems across all sectors relying on this packaging.

Finally, none of these flaws in the initiative could be fixed by the Legislature, since the measure limits any amendments to those that “further the purpose” of the initiative, and only then with a two-thirds supermajority of the Legislature.

Taxpayer Protection

SUPPORT: The Taxpayer Protection and Government Accountability Act

Over the last five years, several significant loopholes have been carved into California’s historic voter approval system for new or increased taxes.

For example, several court of appeal decisions have interpreted a California Supreme Court decision (Upland) to permit local special tax increases with majority voter approval if the tax increase was placed on the ballot by voter initiative, rather than by the local agency’s governing board.

The jurisprudence following the Upland decision has effectively repealed the two-thirds voter approval requirement for local special taxes. The requirement for a supermajority voter approval of local special taxes has been a cornerstone of the tax reform initiated by Proposition 13 in 1978.

The Taxpayer Protection and Government Accountability Act will close this loophole and several others, and will enact new accountability measures, especially information for voters and binding commitments on the period of the tax increase and use of the revenues.

The measure also enacts a new requirement that any statewide tax increases or new taxes, in addition to being approved by a two-thirds majority of the Legislature, also receive majority approval by voters in a statewide election. The initiative also requires that any new fees be approved by the state Legislature.

CalChamber
CalChamber
The California Chamber of Commerce is the largest, broad-based business advocate to government in California, working at the state and federal levels to influence government actions affecting all California business. As a not-for-profit, we leverage our front-line knowledge of laws and regulations to provide affordable and easy-to-use compliance products and services.

Related Articles

Voters Agree with CalChamber Positions: Say ‘No’ to Propositions 29, 30

California voters agreed with the California Chamber of Commerce by giving a resounding “no” to Propositions 29 and 30. Proposition 30 would have increased the tax on personal income above $2 million by 1.75 percentage...

18 Newspapers Across State Reject Proposition 30

Newspapers across California are urging their readers to vote no on Proposition 30, a November ballot measure that proposes to raise the tax on personal income above $2 million by 1.75 percentage points to...

Vote No on Prop 29: 21 Newspapers Across California Reject Prop 29

Newspapers across California are urging their readers to vote no on Proposition 29, a November ballot measure that would require dialysis clinics to maintain, at the dialysis clinic’s expense, at least one licensed physician,...